“Pirate Master” is “Survivor” clone
Friday, June 1st, 2007
There’s just no getting around the comparisons. Both air on CBS. Both are masterminded by Mark Burnett. Both involve wicked mind games, a “tribal council” of sorts, intricate challenges all the way down to very similarly styled graphics. But “Pirate Master” has something that “Survivor” doesn’t: my interest. We have your typical large mob of contestants that you always see at the start of a reality show. It’s hard to differentiate between them all, save for a few notable exceptions. Those people are: Cheryl, a 35 year old district attorney from Sparks, NV (hey, neighbor!), Christian, a 45 year old former football player from Rancho Cucamonga, CA who was born in Nigeria and is known to be the “Nigerian Nightmare” (sweet!), Joy, a 21 year old receptionist from West Columbia, SC who is unfortunate enough to get a black mark AND suffer horrible seasickness (you’d think that’d make you think twice about signing up for a pirate show, but whatever), John, a 25 year old scientist/exotic dancer (yes, that’s not a typo) from Carlisle, MA who really pushes the envelope of creepy when he mistakenly assumes he’s Captain Jack Sparrow’s clone, and Louie, a 43 year old marina owner from Fishing Creek, MD and who also looks almost EXACTLY like “Survivor’s” Rupert. So much so that I have to do double takes all episode long. It’s really eerie.
At any rate, let me give you a quick rundown of the episode: The contestants board a completely wicked awesome looking pirate ship called the Picton Castle, where Aussie Cameron Daddo is our Jeff Probst. The pirates temporarily split up into crews, the Red Crew and Black Crew and their challenge is to go find some treasure. The challenge is very intricately set-up, a Mark Burnett trademark. The Black Crew makes it to the “Sabotage” section first and sets up a blockade for the Red Crew, who is hot on their heels. So they make it to the treasure first. Back on board the boat, they find that the chest includes $40,000 worth of gold. The pirates then nearly unanimously select Joe Don (from Alaska!) as their Captain, only to find out he gets half the gold to do with as he pleases. GAH! The only person who didn’t vote for Joe Don (and who really, really wanted to be Captain himself, darnit!) was John. And he’s pretty ticked off. Louie isn’t too happy either, and proceeds to belly ache. There’s some talk of mutiny (where everyone unanimously votes to mutiny against the captain and he gets sent packing) but that is quashed when Joe Don gives Louie a Black Mark. A Black Mark selects someone for elimination, ultimately. Also selected is John (duh) and Joy (simply as a pawn). John thinks he’s going to be clever and steals the compasses. Yep, all of them. So when everyone goes to “Pirate’s Court” where each selected crewmember has the opportunity to speak their piece. And, predictably, John continues to be a tool. He reveals that he stole the compasses and that if he’s “set adrift”, he’ll take them with him. Joe Don isn’t concerned, he explains how he can tell north from south without a compass. John calls his bluff in a fantastic moment and asks him to find north. Being it’s a rather cloudy night, Joe Don admits he would be better able to tell in the daytime. John looks smugly satisfied. That’s why it was hilarious when it was revealed that the votes UNANIMOUSLY ousted John. He looked like he’d been shocked with a cattle prod. He honestly expected everyone to keep him after his little stunt and I thought that was marvelous. Joe Don sets John adrift on a dinky raft (but I thought it would have been MUCH better had he been forced to walk the plank, HA!) and that, as they say, is that.
All in all, I liked it. I’m interested to see what happens next week. Yes, it’s almost exactly like “Survivor”, but it works. If you happened to catch it last night, what did you think?


Wow, what a difference a few days (and some really poor ratings and reviews) makes! Last night’s “On the Lot” was a completely different show and I mean that in the best way possible. Instead of the “Apprentice”-like format from last week (and we all know how I feel about “The Apprentice”) we had something much more akin to “American Idol”. In fact, if it hadn’t been for the judges and contestants, I probably wouldn’t have recognized this as the same show. Best of all? We finally got to see some of these films! It was “comedy week” and each of the 18 directors had a 1 minute short film to show us. And it felt a lot more like a film festival than a cheesy reality show and that really worked for me. I’m not going to go into all the films and the nitty gritty details (the show was two hours long last night, I’d be sitting here typing all day and we’d have a fricken’ novel on our hands). I will point out my three favorites and the three films that I voted for last night.
We had the second episode of “On the Lot” last night and we got to see some of the fruits of the contestants labors. The 24 hour short film challenge went pretty well, from the clips that I saw. Particularly the one that capitalized on Zach’s talents as a special effects guru. Some were a little off and I was particularly pleased to see the judges call out the team that did the overly stylized by content free short film. We need to see a lot less of that in Hollywood. Sometimes I think movies are called Artsy and Hip because people want us to think they’re Artsy and Hip and that drives me nuts. Anyhow, that’s my issue and not related to last night’s show (much). A bunch of people are eliminated, including Hannah Sink which makes me happy because her name bothered me. Yes, I can be that fickle. Leave me alone. Then the contestants got another challenge: make a short film in ONE HOUR. They’re given the set, the script and a bunch of actors and they have one hour to put it together. I’d tell you when to tune in for the next episode except that I have no idea when it will be. Frankly, I’m a little worried about “On the Lot” because so far its been rather boring, we’ve seen far too little of the films and I haven’t really seen anything to make me care yet. This could be a great show, and I’m just really not seeing it yet. Bummer.
“So You Think You Can Dance” aired it’s season 3 premiere episode last night. It, much like “American Idol” focuses on the auditions at the beginning. So among the people who, you know, can actually DANCE, we had the people who think they can dance. And apparently, much like singing on “American Idol”, a lot of people on “SYTYCD” think they can dance. And they can’t. YIKES. But that’s part of what makes the show so fun. We even had the cranky judge getting all up in some guy’s grill about his complete lack of talent and how this guy is wasting everyone’s time and yet, here they are, showing this whole thing on television and taking time away from the people who can actually dance. So, whatever. People are weird, and this show proves it.
Then, we moved on to “American Idol”. Talk about being down to the wire. After some banter about Paula’s broken nose, we get to the nitty gritty. Blake won the coin toss last episode so he chose to go first. He starts off with his completely awesome rendition of “You Give Love a Bad Name” by Bon Jovi which is even awesomer than the last time. Even Simon is effusive about the performance. Jordin chose to sing “Fighter” by Christina Aquilera and I thought she got a little “screechy” during the middle of the song. Definitely wasn’t her best song. So round one went to Blake, hands down. But the next round, he chose “She Will Be Loved” by Maroon 5 and she chose “A Broken Wing” by Martina McBride, which you’ll remember she rocked rather soundly the first time she sang it. So even though he did a great job with his song, Jordin smoked him during this round. The last round, I thought, was rather unfair. The Idols were told to sing the winner of the songwriter competition’s song, called “This is My Now”. I wouldn’t say it was made for a woman (because it wasn’t), but it was definitely far better suited to Jordin’s style of singing rather than Blake’s. He was frustrated with the song, obviously, but shrugged it off. Jordin did a little better (but I still thought she sounded flat, probably the song’s fault and not hers) and finished off with tears in her eyes, guaranteeing her a healthy chunk of the sympathy vote. Whatever. I so voted for Blake, it’s not even funny. We are treated to Daughtry singing “Home” live on the stage at the end of the show, a very fitting tribute. And I’m still upset that he didn’t win his season. Taylor Hicks is a frickin’ hack. Ahem.
On “Dancing with the Stars”, what else is there to talk about other than who won? I was pleased to see Apolo and Julianne take home the trophy. They deserved it. Laila was a good dancer, but she and Maks lacked the chemistry and all around enjoyment that Apolo and Julianne had. Joey had flair up the ying yang, but he lacked the skills to beat Apolo. Overall, it was a very satisfying end to the show. Just don’t tell that to Laila or Joey. In her words, Laila was pissed to be booted out in third place. And Joey looked very obviously disappointed to come in second. But they had to know the audience loved Apolo. So yay! That’s the sort of reality finale I like to see. However, maybe in the future they can cut it back to one hour tops because two hours for that stuff was TORTURE. They didn’t have near enough content to fill a full two hours and it was awful having to suffer through the drivel to get to the good stuff. Think about that next season, ABC.
Well, I went into last night’s show a little nervous. I’ve been rooting for Apolo and Julianne all along and I was afraid they would drop the ball this evening. This is a very important performance, being the last one before the finale tonight and I was worried that either the pressure would get to this energetic duo or that the judges would backlash against them. And after the first round of dances, a “judge’s choice”, it seemed like my fears were well founded. 
Firstly, we have last night’s “Deadliest Catch” episode. I LOVE the snow crab season. LOVE it. It always seems to be a big ramp up from the king crab season. The weather is nastier, for one thing. We were introduced to a bunch of new greenhorns tonight. Which, correct me if I’m wrong, but wouldn’t you rather be a greenhorn during king crab season than snow crab season? Seriously? Should be interesting to see how they all do. There was also a sequence tonight where someone on another boat got gravely ill and the coast guard had to be called out to rescue him. The guy was literally on his last legs. Lord knows what was wrong with him. But it was intense. We should have some good moments coming up, looks like the weather is going to make things interesting sooner rather than later.
“American Idol” is really getting down to the wire and I’m a little scared. Because I love everyone who is left and I don’t want to see any of them go. But one of them HAS to go and that really bums me out. Tonight, the first songs were selected by the judges. And the contestants did pretty well with them, but Melinda is the only one to really hit it out of the park. Fair enough. The next songs were selected by the producers and Jordin didn’t do maybe as well, Blake did better and Melinda, yet again, did a fabulous job. Tonight we had THREE songs and the third set were the contestants favorite songs. Aww! Fun! Melinda and Jordin did okay and Blake did a really fantastic job and wowed even Simon. But when it comes down to it, it looks as if the judges favor the women in the final two. Simon especially hopes to see Melinda in the final two, no matter what happens. I hate to think of any of these talented people leaving, but I fear it will be Blake. Which is a shame because he’s a fantastic singer and he takes wonderful risks and really tries to keep himself modern in a competition that will often “age” and make corny your average talent-seeker. But I guess we’ll have to wait for the results show. *bites nails nervously*
Yep, it was as expected. Ian and Cheryl were sent packing tonight and rightly so. I mean, how could they overcome the sheer awesomeness that was the other three dancing teams from Monday night? I mean, COME ON. Though I’m still smarting over Len calling Apolo’s fantastic cha cha “raunchy” because it was probably the single most awesome dance I’ve ever seen on that show. I’m hoping he wins because he’s simply fantastic. But then again, the judges have a thing for Laila. She’s good, don’t get me wrong, but I don’t know. Her partner, Maksim, kinda bugs me. I think he’s sort of a jerk. So if I had to predict, I’d say it’ll be Apolo for the win. But then again, I’ve been saying that for weeks now so this should be no surprise to you. I was not sad to Ian go, but I will be sad next week. I feel it might be Joey going home (as it should) and that sorta makes me sad because he’s so much fun to watch. But we are getting down to the wire and it’s time to get serious. Dangit.
Yep, you heard me right. I’m liveblogging the “Amazing Race: All Stars” finale. Woot! I know I may be three hours behind to some of you, but that’s living in the Pacific time zone for you. It’s new to me, that’s what matters.
It was bound to happen, after last week’s “bloodfest”. Mookie’s ousting saved Alex for the time being but he wasn’t near as fortunate this week. Okay, to be entirely honest, Alex’s plight was not helped by Boo winning immunity. Because, apparently, Boo is a twerp. And the rest of the castaways are realizing this. They wouldn’t have minded the chance to get rid of him, even before Alex, but no. The immunity has spoken. So homeward bound was Alex (actually, don’t they go on some vacation? or are they doing jury yet? Is it Friday yet??). They’re all getting pretty annoyed with one another, actually. I guess it’s just gotten to that point in the game already. You spend enough days on a boring island with a bunch of stinky, camera-whoring people and they’re gonna start getting under your skin in a big, big way. So “Bravo!” to them for sticking it out this far because with my tolerance for humanity, I’m not sure i would have lasted this long. 
I wrote up a long, and if I do say so myself, rather brilliant post recapping last night’s “Dancing with the Stars”. It was filled with lots of deep, insightful comments and witty, biting comments. And you know what happened? Just as I was typing the very last sentance of this brilliant recap, my youngest child (a 10 month old baby) banged on the keyboard and amazingly hit a series of keys that entirely deleted all that I had written. (weep) After having a small fit and cursing the 451Press Gods for not upgrading to WordPress 2.1 already (the autosave feature would have certainly saved me), I am back. But am I going to write out another long, brilliant and witty recap? NOPE. I’m suffering from a particularly nasty flu and am laid up and feeling more than a little awful today. I’m amazed I’m even alive this morning, after how I felt last night. So what I’m going to do instead is point you two
Well, this is what I was afraid of. Oswald and Danny couldn’t struggle out of last place last night. I think that even if they had come in second, their “Marked for Elimination” would have seen them gone. I sort of enjoyed them after all. A heck of a lot more than Charla and Mirna or Eric and Danielle. And now, those two cursed teams will be racing for the million. See that? I just got a shiver of dread down my back. Dear God, if the BQ’s don’t win, I may have to throw in the towel on this one.
The important information first: The lowest score (a 19) went to John Ratzenberger and Edyta Sliwinska who danced the mambo. It’s not that he’s that bad, but he’s not that good either. We’re getting down to the wire here and his performances, no matter how charming, just don’t measure up to Laila, Joey or Apolo. And the judges are letting him know that with his score. It’s either get better or get going. And I’m going to predict that John gets going this week. It’s time.
Is it over yet? Nope, not by a long shot. God, I miss Rob and Amber. This week, I continue to want to brutalize Mirna. My feelings are not unusual, people. My husband just last night said, (and I quote) “I just want to bash her face in.” My 70+ year old mother has a strong, STRONG dislike for her. NO ONE likes this woman. Which gets you thinking, how must it be to know that a majority of the world really doesn’t like you? That’d be rough. Doesn’t seem to make her want to start acting any more decently though. UGH. WHY is she and Charla racing so well?? I want them GONE. Bah. Charla, to set the record straight, is a perfectly fine human being. I have no issue with Charla. It’s MIRNA who is the DEVIL.